Sell your cards to a collector who actually cares.
Fair rates. Honest condition grading. Clear communication end-to-end. Whether it's a shoebox of bulk or a stack of slabs, we'll handle it like it's our own.
Three ways to sell.
Singles, slabs, and bulk — all welcome. Mixed submissions are fine; just list them on the form.
Singles
Modern and vintage singles across every game we sell. Chase cards, staples, and sealed-fresh pulls.
Slabs
PSA, BGS, CGC, and TAG graded cards. All grades considered — high-end priority handling available.
Bulk
Commons, uncommons, and playable bulk by the thousand. Fast counts, honest rates, easy shipping.
Transparent buylist pricing.
Baseline rates for unsifted bulk by game. Individual singles are quoted from current market data — your confirmation email lists exact per-card values.
| Game | Singles | Unsifted Bulk (per 1,000) |
|---|---|---|
| Pokémon (English) | up to 70% of market | $10.00 per 1,000 |
| Japanese Pokémon | up to 70% of market | $8.00 per 1,000 |
| Magic: The Gathering | up to 70% of market | $8.00 per 1,000 |
| Star Wars Unlimited | up to 60% of market | $8.00 per 1,000 |
| Dragon Ball Super Fusion World | up to 60% of market | $8.00 per 1,000 |
| Flesh and Blood | up to 60% of market | $8.00 per 1,000 |
| Yu-Gi-Oh! | up to 55% of market | $8.00 per 1,000 |
| One Piece TCG | up to 60% of market | $8.00 per 1,000 |
Rates shown are per-card benchmarks in USD for Near Mint condition. Chase cards, staples, and slabs are quoted individually.
Pack it right, get paid right.
Cards damaged in transit are paid at their received condition — please follow these steps carefully.
Bulk (2,000+ cards)
- Use a USPS Flat Rate shipper box.
- Line the inside of the box with bubble wrap.
- Pack cards unsleeved, tightly stacked so they cannot move or shift.
- Fill every empty space with bubble wrap or packing paper.
- Tape all seams and include your printed packing slip.
Slabs
- Team bag each slab individually.
- Wrap each bagged slab in bubble wrap (2–3 layers).
- Ship in a rigid mailer — no bendable envelopes.
- For multiple slabs, separate each with additional padding.
- Include your printed packing slip.
Singles
- Under $50: penny sleeve → card saver → team bag → plain white envelope with packing slip.
- Over $50: penny sleeve → top loader → team bag → bubble mailer with packing slip.
- Never send raw singles loose in an envelope.
- Group by value tier if sending a mixed submission.
From submission to payout.
A clear, five-step process. No guessing, no waiting in the dark.
- Step 1
Submit your form
Fill out the Tally submission form with your card list, condition notes, and contact info.
- Step 2
Get your packing slip
You'll receive an email confirmation with a PDF packing slip. Print it and include it with your shipment.
- Step 3
Ship it in
Pack per the instructions below and drop it off. Tracked shipping is strongly recommended.
- Step 4
Receipt within 48 hours
Once your package arrives we confirm receipt within 48 hours and begin processing.
- Step 5
Payout within 72 hours
After processing you'll get a final email confirming rate, count, and condition — payout follows within 72 hours of receipt.
Condition & payout disclaimer
All reference rates assume Near Mint (NM) condition.
- Lightly Played / Moderately Played: paid at 50% of the NM rate.
- Heavily Played: paid at 25% of the NM rate.
- Damaged cards are not accepted.
If items arrive in a lower condition than shipped, we can only pay for cards in the condition received. Please follow the packaging instructions above carefully so your payout matches your submission.
Ready to sell? Start with the form.
Fill out the Tally submission form and we'll email your PDF packing slip right away.